How Many Design and Finish Decisions Do I Have to Make When I Build an ADU?
Watch: "Hire Someone Who Handles Everything." Homeowner Advice After Renovation Hell
You think that an ADU is a good choice for your family but you do have one worry. Now somebody has to pick out the flooring, the cabinets, the trim, the fixtures, the paint, and the hardware for all the doors. You are afraid there'll be weeks of trips to the showroom and workers waiting while you try to decide on a faucet. That worry is reasonable and it can keep a family from going forward.
My name is Buz Artiano, founder and CEO of BuildX and we have built lots of ADUs in the state of Massachusetts, mostly on the South Shore and in Plymouth County. Each of these has to deal with the same local rules about septic systems, lot coverage, and also the state's by-right ADU rules in whatever way the town uses them. We do the design, permitting, and construction all in one location and we also help you with all the finishes so they're chosen before we start building.
Howard and Ann Snyder of Plymouth are BuildX clients. We built a one-level ADU that's about 600 square feet for Howard's brother, Larry, that has an accessible bathroom, grab bars, and space to get around. Ann said that if she'd had to design it herself just choosing the type of wood would have taken her months.
You'd think we'd want to share stories about families who were happy with the result. We're telling the Snyders' story because they told us exactly where they thought they'd get stuck, and because they were honest that one of them thought the selection process took longer than he wanted. Their honesty is more useful to you than anything we could say about ourselves.
Quick Answer: When an ADU builder brings you a list of choices, you'll have to make fewer decisions than you think, and you finish them before the construction begins. At BuildX, these selections only take one meeting. The Snyders of Plymouth picked their ADU's design and finish selections in one meeting at BuildX headquarters that took just over two hours. Our team gave them all the options and they approved them. When your ADU is designed from an empty page, you have to make every choice and Ann Snyder estimated that the wood decision by itself would have taken her months.
In This Article
- How Many Decisions Will I Actually Make With a Specialized Builder?
- What Happens in the Selections Meeting?
- Why Does a Prepared Selection Set Shrink My List So Much?
- Can I Still Change Things After the Meeting?
- Questions That Show How a Builder Runs Selections
- Is a Prepared Selection Set Right for Every Homeowner?
- See What Arrives Already Decided Before You Sign
How Many Decisions Will I Actually Make With a Specialized Builder?
The number is up to the builder's model, so that's the first thing you should ask about. A builder who designs every ADU from nothing gives you all the choices: layout, type of wood, cabinet style, tile, plumbing fixtures, lighting, and door hardware, each one picked by you. A builder who does ADUs with many choices already in the plan, means that your part goes from inventing a home to reviewing something and approving or adjusting it.
At BuildX, we do it the second way. The Snyders came to us after they saw a few of our designs and Ann said those designs "just had everything that we needed in it." For them, that meant a one level ADU with a bathroom Larry could actually use, with grab bars, smooth surfaces, and room to turn around in. Because those additions were already in the plan, at the meeting about selections they just approved them instead of needing to design the house from nothing.
We don't decide on how many decisions because it will change with how much you want to adjust. But we can tell you when all those decisions will be made: in one meeting, before construction, with all your choices there. That's the way BuildX does the selections. Other builders will do them differently, so that's why questions later will be so important.
What Happens in the Selections Meeting?
The Snyders' meeting was at BuildX headquarters before any of the construction started. Howard thinks it was over two hours. We, along with Justin from our team, gave them a complete list of selections to choose from and Ann looked it over and said this: "yeah, we'll take that."
What Ann liked best was what didn't happen afterward. Once the build got started, nobody came and asked her an "oh, by the way" question about what kind of doorknobs she wanted. Everything had already been decided in the meeting, and all the hardware was something she'd approved.
The meeting also caused some tension that most couples will understand. Howard got restless but Ann enjoyed herself and said the experience was fabulous. After they moved in both of them said the finish selection part was like a candy store. If you and your spouse make decisions differently, plan on having one long meeting that one of you will like better than the other one. Out of that you get selections that are finished before the building crew gets there.
Why Does a Prepared Selection Set Shrink My List So Much?
Ann gave the reason: "you guys don't build 75 different kinds of houses." That's just what she said in her words. It wasn't a count of all our plans, it was about specializing. Because we build ADUs, the things that delay homeowners have already figured out on earlier projects. As Ann put it, everything was already done ahead of time. She told us the exact question that would have stopped her: whether to use fir, oak, or maple. If the design page is blank then that question has to be answered by the homeowner but with a list of options you change it only if you want something else.
We decide on selections before the construction starts for a good reason. Every finish we pick in that meeting is something we can order, schedule and then give to the right workers when the time is right. A finish that's not decided on by the time the walls are going up is a question the workers have to stop and ask and those questions in the middle of the building process can mean a change order. A change order is a written change to the contract after it's been signed. It can happen before construction starts or during the construction and it will add cost, time or both. Closing selections before the build keeps those questions out of your schedule.
The Snyders' project shows what the benefit of sequencing is. One person who has experience in construction, said the biggest problem are change orders and they didn't need them for this project.
Can I Still Change Things After the Meeting?
Yes, the selections that you okay are just a starting point and you can adjust them later during the process. The Snyders did make a few changes to our design, adding a window here and there, but kept all the rest just like we showed them. On one of our ADU home tours, the 900-square-foot, one-bedroom, one-bath ADU, was customized for its owner. A prepared set gives you a finished baseline, and you can decide how much you want to change it.
You will still have questions after the construction starts and the way the builder answers them is just as important as the selections themselves. The Snyders said Justin kept them informed the whole time, answered their texts right away, and handled every question they had for him. If you know who to call it keep the questions you have from turning into a guess about a finish.
Questions That Show How a Builder Runs Selections
The number of decisions will depend on the model you are shown by the builder, so the most useful thing you can do when you're comparing different builders is ask each one how selections work before you sign anything. These questions are what helped to make the Snyders' experience work:
- Do your plans come with the finishes already chosen or do I start from a blank page?
- Do all selections have to happen before construction starts, and on what date?
- Will I see every option in this one meeting, or will I need to have separate trips to the showroom?
- Who will offer options, your team or me?
- What happens if I want to change a finish after I have approved the set?
If a builder can't tell you when selections close, then there will be decisions that you have to make in the middle of the build. That open-ended process is exactly the "oh, by the way" moment Ann was happy not to deal with.
Is a Prepared Selection Set Right for Every Homeowner?
Since we build our ADUs using a prepared plan, you'd expect that we think this approach works for everybody. A prepared set is the wrong thing for some homeowners. If choosing each type of wood, and each handle and fixture yourself is something you look forward to doing, then a prepared plan will seem like we did your favorite part for you. If you want every detail to start from nothing you'll be happier with a company who starts with a blank page, and you should plan on months of deciding that will come with it.
For the Snyders, the trade worked out. Ann knew the wood question alone would stall things, and Howard wanted the decisions done so the building could start. If you don't have a lot of time or confidence, or you're building the ADU for a family member who's counting on you, then you're in the same situation they were. And a prepared selection set is right for you.
See What Arrives Already Decided Before You Sign
How many decisions you make is up to the builder you choose. The fastest way to judge whether a prepared selection set fits your family is to see one in person and have a discussion with the people that run the meeting.
We'll take you through a complete selection set, show you what comes already decided, and schedule your selections meeting so every finish is settled before construction starts.
Tour a finished ADU and its finishes in person or Request a Free Consultation
Call us: (781) 627-7000
