How Do You Know an ADU Heat Pump Is Sized Right?
Watch: Designing Concepts & Tools for Net Zero Homes w/ Gwendolen St. Sauveur | BuildX Podcast #18
The heat pump is the one part of your ADU you never watch anyone decide. A contractor reviews the plans, and a model number appears on the quote. If that unit is too small, the ADU runs cold on the hardest nights of a Massachusetts winter. If it is too big, you paid for capacity the space never uses. There is something for you to check, and asking for it takes one sentence.
My name is Buz Artiano, founder of BuildX. We have built dozens of ADUs across Massachusetts, mostly on the South Shore and in Plymouth County, and every one of them runs through the same local realities: septic evaluation, lot coverage limits, and the state's by-right ADU rules. We handle design, permitting, and construction ourselves, so we are also the ones that help you figure out the best HVAC equipment for your project.
On episode 18 of the BuildX Podcast, we talked about heat pump sizing with Gwendolen St. Sauveur. Gwendolen is a mechanical engineer and she started a business called BTF Net Zero Designs in Vermont. She teaches builders to run their own load calculations. Her point was just that the size of your heat pump comes from a calculation, and you should be able to see that if you want, and a single design decision on your plans can change it.
Quick Answer: You know an ADU heat pump is the correct size when it uses two certain calculations for your specific ADU, and you've seen both of them before anything is ordered. A "Manual J" totals the heat your ADU loses on the coldest night and how much it gains on a hot summer day, based on its walls, roof, windows, air tightness, and shape. A "Manual S" then checks the model of heat pump you are looking at against your actual local temperatures. Ask your builder or HVAC contractor to show and explain to you both numbers so you can make sure they match your final plans, and ask whether any design features forced the system to be bumped up a size.
In This Article
- How Do I Know My ADU Heat Pump Was Sized Right?
- What Goes Into a Heat Pump Load Calculation?
- Can One Design Choice Push My ADU Into a Bigger Heat Pump?
- Why Would a Heat Pump Get Sized Wrong?
- Isn't Heat Pump Sizing the HVAC Contractor's Job?
- Do I Need to Run My Own Manual J?
- Ready to See the Math Behind Your ADU's Heat Pump?
How Do I Know My ADU Heat Pump Was Sized Right?
You just ask for the Manual J and the Manual S. Both are methods published by the Air Conditioning Contractors of America (ACCA). The Manual J is the load calculation we talked about. It adds up all the places that heat leaks out of your ADU in the winter, through the walls, roof, floor, windows, doors, and air leaks, and it also calculates the heat and moisture that come in during summer. The Manual S tells you what equipment to use. It compares a specific heat pump's performance against those specific numbers, and that's how they should decide what model you will need.
The Manual S matters because a heat pump's output changes when the outside temperature changes. A unit rated to give you certain performance on a mild day isn't going to perform as well on a cold night. The selection has to show the model's heating output at those low temperatures, its cooling and moisture removal in summer, and its lowest output. If they can't show you those numbers then they are just guessing at what equipment you need.
Gwendolen's concern is that on most jobs whoever sells the equipment runs the numbers and everyone else just believes it. You don't have to run the calculation yourself, you just need to see it, and it should describe the ADU on your plans. Check three things on your paperwork:
- Make sure your current plans show every bump out, dormer, and window on the final drawings.
- The Manual S shows the selected model's heating output at that low temperature, not just its rated capacity.
- It uses whole-wall R-values that account for the framing, not the rating printed on the insulation.
What Goes Into a Heat Pump Load Calculation?
A Manual J is built from your ADU's shell, which is often called an "envelope". The envelope is everything that separates heated space from the outdoors. So basically walls, roof, floor or slab, windows, and doors. Each one of those things has what's called an R-value, which is the number that tells you how well it resists heat. That Manual J calculation applies those ratings over the outside surface of the home, and adds up how much heat leaks out through the building.
There is one part of the calculations that people often don't know about. The insulation inside a wall isn't continuous, it's got wood studs in between, and wood does not resist heat as well as insulation does. Gwendolen calls that "the framing factor", she says that the studs cost a wall 20 to 25 percent of its R-value. A calculation that uses the number on the insulation package instead of the total for the whole wall minus the studs is not correctly calculating the heat loss. She recommends using the free assembly calculator from Ekotrope because it gives you the numbers with that framing factor already calculated in.
In northern climates, Gwendolen's experience is that the winter temperatures are what determine the size of heat pump you need. But for summer, the Manual J also calculates the cooling load, including the moisture the system has to remove from the air. What can happen is if you pick a unit based on winter temps, sometimes it will cool the ADU so quickly during the summer that it actually turns off before it has time to remove that moisture. The outdoor design temperatures for your town, winter and summer, are two of the most important things that have to go on the report. A Vermont night and a South Shore night are different numbers.
Can One Design Choice Push My ADU Into a Bigger Heat Pump?
Yes. Gwendolen's example was something called a "bump out", which is just a section of wall that projects past the main outside wall of a building for something like a bay or a window seat. She talked about how sometimes a designer will run the numbers and realize "this bump out is going to kick me up to a bigger size heat pump." She says the best thing to do at that point is reconsider whatever is causing the bump out.
It's just basic geometry. A bump out adds extra exterior wall, roof edge, and foundation perimeter, but it doesn't add much space, and any additional outside surface is another place for heat to escape. Heat pumps are sold in certain capacities. When the load is just slightly more than the current unit can handle, you have to bump up to the larger unit, which is more expensive. A single-speed unit that's too big for what you need will run in these very short on-and-off cycles, which wastes a lot of energy and doesn't keep your living space evenly heated or cooled. A variable-capacity unit, called an inverter heat pump, slows down to match the demand, so the number to check is its minimum output. When the ADU's load on a mild day falls below that minimum, even a variable-capacity unit cycles.
This is part of the cost that you have more control over, but you have to make decisions during the design phase. Once the framing is up, the heat pump has to go along with whatever your plan says. Ask your designer directly whether you've got any features that will bump you up into the next size, and decide whether you want to change that or not.
Why Would a Heat Pump Get Sized Wrong?
Gwendolen raised the uncomfortable version of this question on the podcast. When a supplier hands you a size, she said it's no problem to directly ask "are they just giving me what they have too much of on the shelf?"
Equipment lines and models change constantly as well. Gwendolen noted that manufacturers are reworking many of their heat pump lines because refrigerants have actually changed. When we asked her what we should see on a spec sheet, she said the capacity the unit needs and the low temperature it has to reach, no need for a certain brand. It should still perform the way it says even if they discontinue that model.
There is another way these calculations can go wrong, and it happens on site. A Manual J treats two things on the drawings as fact. The first is insulation, which slows heat moving through the walls and roof. Its performance depends on the installer doing a thorough job and making sure every little gap is filled, and you will find that they don't all do that. The second thing is the air barrier, the continuous layer of sheathing, tape, and sealant that stops heated air from leaking out through gaps. Gwendolen made the point that it is hard to get a leak proof wall using fiberglass, because fiberglass doesn't stop air from moving, it just resists heat. Air tightness is measured separately with a blower door test, which pressurizes the building and measures how much air leaks out through small places. A heat pump sized for the drawing won't be big enough for a house of the same size that isn't sealed properly, so both of those things we talked about have to be checked and double checked.
Isn't Heat Pump Sizing the HVAC Contractor's Job?
It is, but you should still get to see the work. Gwendolen's view is that load calculation is "a tool you don't learn unless you get the job that makes you do it," and that everyone in the trade needs it now "with how tight we're building." A building that is air tight needs less heat, so a heat pump that would work for an older house that leaks a lot of air will be too much for a modern ADU.
Asking for the Manual J is a fair question for you to ask any builder. A builder who's confident about their HVAC choices is happy to give you that. If the answer is that the supplier deals with it and they can't show you any paperwork, that's a big red flag.
Do I Need to Run My Own Manual J?
You would expect a builder to tell you to leave the mechanical math to the professionals and stop there, but the truth is that you don't need to run your own Manual J, and you shouldn't accept a number blindly either. Ask for the calculation, read it against your plans, and ask as many questions as you want until it really makes sense to you.
The training Gwendolen provides is mostly for builders. Her course on HeatSpring, which is an online education platform for the building trades, takes about four to five hours, and by the end a builder can run a load calculation on a house or ADU the correct way. HeatSpring also offers free classes, but Gwendolen said that hers is not free.
Ready to See the Math Behind Your ADU's Heat Pump?
A heat pump is sized right when the load calculation and the equipment both match the ADU you're building. Ask for them before the equipment is ordered, and use it to decide which design features are worth the capacity they add.
We'll walk through the plans for your property, show you which design choices move your heating and cooling loads, and review the heat pump selection with you before any equipment is ordered.
Walk through a completed ADU and its heat pump or Request a Free Consultation
Call us: (781) 627-7000
