Does the Rough Sill Under an ADU Window Need a Slope?
Watch: Window Delays, Install Fails and What Builders Always Miss w/ Chad Nicoli | BuildX Podcast #25
You asked one builder whether the bottom of your ADU window openings should be taped, and he told you no, the window company says to leave it open. But when you asked a different builder, they said that if you don't tape the bottom you can get water into the wall. Both builders were confident with their answers. You are the one paying for everything, so you need a solid answer to this question before you start building.
My name is Buz Artiano, founder of BuildX. We have built dozens of ADUs across Massachusetts, concentrated on the South Shore and Plymouth County, and we do all of the design, permitting, and construction. That means we work through the septic evaluation, lot coverage limits, and the state's ADU rules before a single window is ever ordered.
We asked Chad Nicoli about this specifically on our podcast. He's a trade sales manager for Pella Windows and Doors in Eastern Massachusetts. His company recommends leaving the bottom of the window flange open. When we asked what slope the rough sill needs for that to work, he didn't know the exact degrees of what that slope should be at that moment, but his company's installation instructions have that information. That number and the details around it are important because they decide whether the bottom of your windows leaks or not.
Quick Answer: Yes. When a window is installed with the bottom part left open so it can drain, the surface under it has to angle downwards so water runs out instead of back toward the house. Pella shows two ways to build that slope in its published instructions for nail-fin windows. It says that you should use a strip of cedar bevel siding on the sill, or framing cut at a 5-degree angle. That number comes from instructions for a specific product, it's not a general rule for all windows. Ask your builder how the slope is built on your openings and which written instructions for your specific window it matches.
In This Article
- Does the Rough Sill Under My ADU Window Need a Slope?
- Is the Slope Cut Into the Framing or Built On Top of It?
- What Does the Manufacturer's Open-Bottom Method Ask of My Builder?
- Why Do We Say an Open Bottom Fails on a Flat Sill?
- How Much Slope Does My Rough Sill Need?
- Which Answers From My Builder Should Worry Me?
- Is Leaving the Bottom Open Ever the Right Call?
- What Will You Ask Before Your ADU Windows Go In?
Does the Rough Sill Under My ADU Window Need a Slope?
Yes, the sill needs a slope whenever the bottom of the window is left open to drain. That's the one thing that everybody we talked to agreed on. When we asked Chad about how water escapes through an open bottom, Chad said that the sill has to be at an angle, enough to let the water run out. Later in the same conversation he reiterated that there has to be some slope.
The open-bottom method only works if the surface under the window pitches toward the outside. A flat sill gives water nowhere to go, and a sill that's at the wrong angle will cause water to run into the walls between the outside and the drywall.
Is the Slope Cut Into the Framing or Built On Top of It?
The rough sill is the wood that runs across the bottom of the window. The drainage surface is whatever the flashing and the window actually sit on. They can be the same piece of wood or sometimes it's just two separate pieces.
Pella's instructions for nail-fin windows over house wrap show that you can do it both ways. One builds the slope on top of a flat rough sill with a piece of cedar bevel siding. The other uses just one piece, it cuts the framing itself at 5-degrees. Either way, flashing tape is then put from there out and down over the face of the house wrap, and then shims are set in the opposite direction so the window itself still sits level.
So the question for your builder isn't whether that's installed, it's how it's installed. A bevel cut into the framing has to be cut very accurately with a saw, if not, the setup will fail. But just the same, a strip of bevel siding depends on the installer setting it with the thick edge toward the inside, if that's not done properly it will fail as well.
What Does the Manufacturer's Open-Bottom Method Ask of My Builder?
Every window we install has a flange or a nail-fin, which are just two different terms for a thin strip around the outside edge of the frame of the window that hooks to the frame. Flashing tape is an adhesive membrane that causes water to go shed away from the window opening. It covers that flange where it meets the wall. In the open-bottom method, the sides and top are sealed and taped, and the bottom is left open so any water that works its way behind the window has a way to get out rather than just sitting there causing damage you won't find out about until later.
Chad walked us through the order his company does things. Flash the sill and carry it about three to four inches up each side, then set and shim the window, confirm that it's still square, secure it, and foam it. He was clear about the fact that that is what Pella recommends, and that's what he goes by.
Why Do We Say an Open Bottom Fails on a Flat Sill?
Our question to Chad is the one every homeowner should ask their builder as well. If water gets in there, what makes you think it is going to go out rather than coming back into the house? Chad's answer was the angle. Then we asked him who put the sill on the angle, because that's a very important question.
When the slope is cut into the framing, we always watch that very closely, because the rough sill is cut and set by the framing crew a long time before the windows get there. It fails when a framer is moving too fast and his saw cut is off by two degrees, and that causes the sill to angle toward the house instead of away from it. The flange and siding cover the outside, the trim covers the inside, so the first thing you'll see is a stain on the drywall under the window. Chad's response was that it sounds like a problem with the builder. The open bottom puts the outcome in the hands of whoever built the sill.
Our second reason is air pressure. In the right conditions a house has negative pressure inside of it, so outside air and the water can get pulled inside through any little gap or opening. On a flat sill, we believe that an open bottom becomes a place for water to come in, not go out. We told Chad we've seen it happen. That's our judgment from the field, not a scientifically proven result.
The manufacturer's instructions deal with the water from inside, not by closing up the bottom of the window. Pella keeps the drainage opening and stops air leaks inside using special foam for windows and doors, which fills the first inch or so of the gap from the inside, and then a sealant bridges across every shim so the foam forms one continuous air seal. Exterior drainage and interior air sealing are two separate things, but they have to work together. In that method, the interior seal is what deals with the pressure problem, and the open bottom lets water out.
How Much Slope Does My Rough Sill Need?
On the podcast, we weren't given an exact number for this. We asked Chad directly whether his company recommends that builders put a five degree slope on their rough sills. Chad said he didn't know the number, but there is definitely a slope. Pella's published instructions do give specific instructions though. They say to use cedar bevel siding, or framing cut at a 5-degree bevel.
That is just the instructions for Pella for a certain type of window, it's not a universal rule for all products and manufacturers. Install details will be different depending on the brand and type of window. Chad gave us an example. His company's newer install system for wood-clad windows actually has little grooves at the bottom for the water to run off from. So you'll need to ask for the specific instructions for the exact window you are installing in your ADU, and have your builder show you where it talks about the slope requirement.
Which Answers From My Builder Should Worry Me?
The builder you hire doesn't necessarily have to agree with us, but they need to be able to tell you what method they use and why and if your windows fit that. If you get any of these answers, it means that the builder hasn't really thought the process through:
- Leaving the bottom flange open but gives you no answer on the slope part of it
- Quoting an amount for a slope without knowing which manufacturer's instructions it came from
- Leaving out that interior air seal around the frame and shims
- Treating the rough sill as the framer's business alone
A good answer would sound something like this: here is how we build the slope, here is the instruction it matches, here is how we seal the interior, and here is who checks the sill before the window covers it.
Is Leaving the Bottom Open Ever the Right Call?
We said that the open bottom was a bad idea on our own podcast, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't deal with any builder who leaves it open. It depends on the manufacturer's published instructions, Chad told us they see it done both ways.
Our objection is mostly to the version that has pieces missing when it gets to the job site. An open bottom on a flat sill, or on a sill nobody checked, is not acceptable on our jobs. The open bottom is a system. Take away the slope or the interior seal, and that system no longer works.
What Will You Ask Before Your ADU Windows Go In?
You do not need to settle a debate between a window company and a builder. You need clear answers before the first window is set: how your builder builds the sill slope, which written instructions for your window line it matches, and how the interior gets sealed. If those answers come back clear and specific, you can trust the bottom of every opening in your ADU.
We'll walk you through how we build the sill slope, which window line fits your ADU, and what its installation instructions require before a single unit is ordered.
Walk through a finished ADU and see the window details or Request a Free Consultation
Call us: (781) 627-7000
