What Do Small ADU Floor Plans Leave Out? (Bathroom Windows, Linen Closets, and Bedroom Storage)
Watch: Jessica Way ADU Mid-Construction Walkthrough | BuildX Update
You've been looking at floor plans and this one has enough square footage. The kitchen is open to the living room, you can put a queen size bed in the bedroom, and the builder just needs for you to sign. Families sometimes have regrets about what the plan left off for their small ADU, and that shows up after the walls have been framed, so fixing it means tearing the framing out.
My name is Buz Artiano, and I'm the founder and CEO of BuildX. We've built lots of ADUs in the state of Massachusetts, mostly on the south shore and in Plymouth County. The company does the design, permits and construction from one location. We will help with the size of the septic, the lot coverage and the ADU permits that the state needs before a plan gets to the framing stage. And we inspect our own jobs half through the construction, on camera, and that's where any problems with the floor plan will show up.
We have three issues with a small ADU plan, and we tell you about them when we look at the construction: no window in the bathroom, no linen closet, and bedrooms that don't have closets. Each of these can be fixed quickly if the floor plan is just on paper but can mean part of the ADU has to be torn down if the framing is already done. Each time we check, we show you how this was fixed on a 900 square foot ADU, so you can see what the answer is on an actual drawing.
Quick Answer: The three things left out that we look for in small ADU floor plans are a window in the bathroom, a linen closet, and a closet in all the bedrooms. With the 900 square foot Jessica's Way build, we had room for all of those. The bathroom has a window that's up high to let in natural light. The linen closet is six feet long with a four-foot-wide bypass door, and has lots of shelves inside. The bedroom closet has six-foot bypass doors. These sizes are how we fixed it for this ADU. You should check your plan for all three things before you sign so they can be changed with no problem.
In This Article
What Are the Three Omissions We Watch For in Small ADU Plans?
The three things we check for at the site are a bathroom with no window, a bathroom that doesn't have a linen closet, and bedrooms that don't have a closet. These are what we call our three pet peeves and we will be honest about the last one. It's crazy that someone will build a bedroom without a closet and we don't know why they do it.
None of these things are just a luxury for the bigger ADUs. The one on Jessica's Way is 900 square feet on top of a two-car garage. It's got nine-foot ceilings, large windows, a kitchen that opens into the living room, and a big master bedroom. It still has a bathroom window, a linen closet, and a large bedroom closet. We know 900 square feet sounds small. But our list still fits, and this ADU proves it to the people we show it to.
Does My ADU Bathroom Need a Window?
If you want daylight, yes. On Jessica's Way there's a window up high to let the outside light come in, and daylight's our reason for it. A bathroom is a room you use first thing in the morning and last thing at night, and a window will give it daylight so it isn't just lit by a light on the ceiling.
A bathroom window has to be planned when you plan the room. A bathroom window has to be one of its walls on the outside of the building. When a designer puts the bathroom into the middle of the plan, surrounded by the bedroom, the hall, and the kitchen, there's no wall for the window to go on. That choice is settled when you arrange the rooms, and that's weeks before you order windows. So that's why we pick where the bathroom's going to be during the layout part of every plan we draw.
On the drawings check the floor plan for a window symbol on the bathroom wall, then look at the drawings that show the outside of the building and check for the same window on those. If the bathroom doesn't have an outside wall, ask the designer if the plan can be changed. If you add a window after framing you'll have to cut through the sheathing, that's the structural panel nailed to the outside of the frame, and put in a header. That's the part that takes the weight over an opening. Then insulation, siding and outside finishes will need to be patched around the new hole.
How Big Should a Linen Closet Be in a Small ADU?
On Jessica's Way the linen closet is six feet long and has bypass doors that are four feet wide, with lots of shelves inside. That's how we fixed storage with this one, and a different plan might fix it with a different size. A bypass door is a pair of panels that slide along tracks and pass each other. They don't have to have any floor space because they don't swing open, so the bathroom stays clear even if the door's in use.
Our reasons make sense. Everybody has towels, everybody has stuff, and all that has to have someplace to go. When a plan leaves out the linen closet, the towels end up in a bedroom closet or a kitchen cabinet, and not close to the shower.
Our standard has a floor built into it: a linen closet in the bathroom, or at least a linen cabinet. If the room cannot hold a full closet, a tall cabinet with shelves still answers the need. A bathroom with neither fails the check.
On the drawings, find the closet or cabinet on the floor plan and confirm its width is written next to it. A closet drawn with no dimension, or a cabinet that appears on the plan with no shelving noted, earns a question before you sign. Our six-foot closet is one working example. What matters on your plan is that the storage exists and is dimensioned.
Should Every Bedroom in My ADU Have a Closet?
In every plan we draw, yes. The master bedroom on Jessica's Way has a big closet with six-foot bypass doors, the size that fits this room. With bypass doors, the closet sits behind panels that slide instead of swing, so a bed or dresser can sit near the closet wall without blocking the doors.
This is the worst of our three pet peeves. When people build bedrooms without any closets, it makes no sense to us. A bedroom with no closet means clothes have to go into other types of wardrobes or dressers and in a small room that extra furniture takes up just as much floor space as a closet would.
We're not talking about a building code requirement for bedroom closets. This is just something we require on our own plans, separate from any code question. On the drawings, every room that's called a bedroom should have a closet with the width labeled and the type of door on it, whether it's a bypass, swing or pocket one.
Why Do Small Plans Drop These Items in the First Place?
The reason families are given is square footage. Every foot of the closet takes away floor space from a bedroom or a hall, and a bathroom window needs an outside wall that the designer wanted for the living room. The answer we give is that it's only 900 square feet, but if you're creative, you can make it all work.
Jessica's Way started as our X3 plan, the Haven, and then we changed it slightly and renamed it X7, the Gables, because it's on top of a two-car garage. The finished plan still has nine-foot ceilings, big windows, an open kitchen and living area, and a nice big master bedroom. Putting in a bathroom window, linen closet, and the bedroom closet didn't take any of these things out of the plan. It's all inside the 900 square feet.
The timing will decide how much each fix costs. When you are drawing the plan, adding a closet just means you have to move a line. But after framing, the same change involves framing a new wall, new drywall, moving outlets and switches and then you have a room that's smaller than you wanted. A window is the same kind of issue. The cheapest time to fix any of these three things is when the plan is being reviewed, and the most expensive time is after the framing has been inspected.
How Do I Check a Builder's Drawing Set Before I Sign?
Make sure you ask your builder the following three questions during the review of the plan, whether they're our drawings or someone else's:
- Does the bathroom have an outside wall, and is there a window drawn on both the floor plan and the elevation?
- Does the bathroom have a linen closet or linen cabinet, and is the width written on the plan?
- Does every room that's a bedroom have a closet, with its width and kind of door marked?
If any of these answers are no, then get a revised drawing before you agree to the plan. Just for your information, our ADU had a six-foot linen closet with a four-foot bypass door and six-foot bypass doors for the bedroom closet. That was the answer for this one and your plan could decide on different sizes. The test is if all three are drawn in and have sizes as well as a builder who checks the finished ADU and understands the question as soon as you ask it.
Is a Plan Missing One of These Always the Wrong Plan?
These are our pet peeves, so you'd think we would insist on them. But sometimes there are reasons to compromise. A linen cabinet can be a reasonable substitute for us sometimes when a full closet won't fit. A size limitation for the lot or a layout that's connected to the main house might mean the bathroom can't have an outside wall. When that happens, the best idea is to ask the designer what the tradeoff got you.
These three issues don't deal with the foundation, the mechanical systems, or the builder's schedule at all. A plan can have all three of these and still not be the right one for your family. Be sure you talk to more than one builder, and take the same checklist to each one so you can compare their answers. Any good designer can draw a bathroom window and a bedroom closet. The question to ask is did they draw them in before you had to ask them about it.
Want a Second Set of Eyes on Your ADU Floor Plan Before It Is Framed?
These three checks only take minutes and you should do them before the crew comes to frame your ADU. Bring your drawings, ours or anyone else's, and we'll go over them with you.
We'll review your drawing set for the bathroom window, linen storage, and bedroom closets, and show you where each one fits on your plan before framing starts.
Walk through a finished ADU with all three or Request a Free Consultation
Call us: (781) 627-7000
